home recipes archives press reader raves about  
 
 

In this Issue: Pie Revival Buttered Maple Walnut Pie, Peaches 'n' Cream, Food Yarns Gale Gand's Brooklyn Blackout Cake, Vintage Summer Coolers Meier & Frank Summer Girl Soda, Watermelon Ice, Reader Favorites Creamy Nectarine-y Cheesecake, Alanbess Luncheonette Chicken Scampi, Tiki-Tiki Chicken in Parchment, Fanny's of Evanston Fried Chicken, Old Virginia Club BBQ Chicken, London Chophouse Roquefort Burger with Pancho Sauce, State Fair Favorites Jim Woodworth's Delicious Honey Apple Pie, Jo Ryman Scott's Orange Delight Cookies, Barb Schaller's Sister Mary's Corn Relish, Gerry Frank's World's Best Chocolate Cake, Restaurant Recipes Then & Now Doris & Ed's Soft-Shell Crab BLT, Doris & Ed's Classic Soft-Shell Crab, Books to Buy Mary Mac's Tea Room Blackberry Sonker, Better Left Lost SPAMoni

 

Editor's Note

My high-summer highs list has sweet corn (roadside), stone fruits, watermelon and BBQ in it. So does this July issue :) Here you'll find recipes for sweet corn relish, watermelon ice, BBQ chicken Old Virginia-style and more. We serve up some decadent vintage chocolate cakes: Chef Gale Gand's re-creation of Ebinger's of Brooklyn's Blackout Cake (click on the Food Yarns button on the far right to hear our interview with Gale), and, Gerry Frank's favorite from 50 years of judging the chocolate layer-cake competition at the Oregon State Fair. Our new feature "Restaurant Recipes Then & Now" kicks off with Jersey shore soft-shell crab recipes from Doris & Ed's. Behind the scenes we've been busy e-mailing you recipes found in response to your requests--you'll see more of those appear at the site each month. We love hearing from you--keep writing & keep cool!

Gale Gand's Brooklyn Blackout Cake

Brooklyn Ebinger's fans, rejoice! The Blackout Cake is back, thanks to the re-creation efforts of Chicago-based chef and baker Gale Gand. As Gale tells it: "Ebinger''s was a chain of bakeries in Brooklyn renowned for the purity of its ingredients, the sparkling cleanliness of its stores, and the deep chocolatiness of this cake. Even though the last Ebinger's finally closed in 1972, devotees kept Blackout Cakes in their freezers for years afterwards." Recreating the cake, Gand didn't have access to one of these freezer fossils for analyzation purposes. Instead, she relied on the taste-memories of Ebinger's fans who grew up in Brooklyn. Says Gand, "They're a tough crowd, but they tell us we've finally got it right. The custard filling is finally the perfect deep, velvety, very, very, dark brown."

Gale Gand's Brooklyn Blackout Cake

Buttered-Maple Black Walnut Pie

Oh, the resourcefulness of youth! When traditional nutcrackers failed to split the rock-hard black walnuts we brought home from the farmers market, my 11-year-old son happily headed out to the sidewalk with a nice, big brick. A smashingly successful hour later, he had enough nutmeats to make this pie. We've acutally had several requests for black-walnut pie. This one's a good un'.

Buttered Maple Walnut Pie

Peaches and Cream Pie

We found this simple, mildly-flavored peach pie recipe reader Honoria M. was looking for, on a very old Betty Crocker recipe insert that had once been included with sacks of Gold Medal flour. We sent the recipe to her, post haste, and Honoria says she received rave reviews for the pie she baked with it: "...just as I remember, it was easy as pie to make, ergo, my Grandmother would have made it!" In this recipe, because the peaches are baked as halves (as opposed to being thinly sliced) the pure flavor of peach really comes through. Choose the best peaches you can find, to make the most of that. We used super-sweet white peaches.

Peaches 'n' Cream

Meier & Frank Summer Girl Soda

Creamy raspberry, orange and vanilla in frothy foam... it's no wonder the Meier & Frank department-store chain called this the Summer Girl Soda! According to fourth-generation Frank family-member Gerry Frank, generations of sweet-loving Frank family members pretty much ensured that the soda-fountain creations, and desserts served in the Meier-Frank department store restaurants would be worth coming back for. While the stores, and their restaurants are gone, this signature recipe--a long-time best seller--is worth reviving.

Meier & Frank Summer Girl Soda

Watermelon Ice

Pink, summer shimmery, refreshing, this easy-to-make icy blend of sweetened frozen melon presents lots of summer possibilities. You can make popsicles, blocks or cubes of it...experiment!

Watermelon Ice

Creamy Nectarine-y Cheesecake

Creamy cool and sunny as the summer nectarines it includes, this light, fruit-flecked cheesecake was requested by reader Marge. Marge remembered making it for her mom's 70 birthday. Now, she's looking forward to having her daughter make it for her. The old-fashioned not-too-sweet crust is made with zweiback toast instead of graham crackers. We've included a recipe for zweiback, in case you can't find store-bought.

Creamy Nectarine-y Cheesecake

Alanbess Luncheonette Chicken Scampi

Gary Allen has a way-- a wayward, winding way--with words: especially when describing memorable food moments from his own colorful youth. (Go to www.onthetable.us for an illustrative sampling.) But Allen's recent write-up about "The Underground Gourmet Cookbook," full of New York restaurant recipe gems hunted down by Milton Glaser & Jerome Snyder in the '70s, went straight to the point: Great book. Great cheap meals. Great recipes. Many of these restaurants are long gone, which makes the recipes more of a treasure: Blue Cheese and Apple Crepes form Belcrep, Chicken Scampi from Alanbess Luncheonette; rich meatless classics from Jewish dairy restaurants The Grand, Hammer's, Hershey's and Gefen's. I dove in to Amazon.com for my 95 cent copy. You can too! There were several copies left, last I checked. Here is one of the recipes:

Alanbess Luncheonette Chicken Scampi

Tiki-Tiki Chicken in Parchment

Hot, gin-soaked, hoisin-glazed chicken and scallions...This appetizing appetizer recipe was a signature at The Islander restaurant in Los Angeles in the '50s. To make it, you deep-fry little packets of gin-spiked marinated chicken with onions. Yum! We like the result served in lettuce cups.

Tiki-Tiki Chicken in Parchment

Fanny's of Evanston's Fried Chicken

From the time it opened in 1946 until it closed in 1987, Fanny's of Evanston was known for its unusual orange juice/pecan/chutney salad dressing, spaghetti with meat sauce, and fried chicken. You can still buy the dressing and the meat sauce from the Bianucci family's Worldwide Foods online (www.fannysofevanston.com) Not so, the chicken. But now, you can make the chicken yourself at home! (Thank you, Helen Bianucci!) The recipe has a really-truly "knock-knock" story to it: Upon opening, Fanny (a woman of faith) prayed for a cook. Two days later, Bob Jordan knocked at the restaurant door announcing "The Lord sent me to be your cook." To Fanny's "what-do-you-cook?" query, Jordan answered, "The best fried chicken around!" Hyperbole notwithstanding, we think Jordan's recipe, which he prepared at Fanny's for 25 years, has phenomenal flavor. Really a fricassee,(i.e. not crispy) this rich, fall-off-the-bones rendition has cream in the coating and butter in the dish.

Fanny's of Evanston Fried Chicken

Old Virginia Club Barbecued Chicken

Last issue, we hinted around that we'd include some barbecue sauce recipes for you. Chicago BBQ king, Gary Wiviott says he'll come through with an heirloom-ish recipe for the outdoor grill soon, but in the meantime, we dredged up this golden oldie from Virginia, plus another spirit-spiked pseudo-BBQ: Tiki-Tiki chicken, also in this issue.

Old Virginia Club BBQ Chicken

London Chop House Roqueburger with Pancho Sauce

Among many satisfying meat dishes at Detroit's London Chop House in the '60s, Chef Philip "Pancho" Valez was known for this blue-cheese-and-brandy stuffed Roqueburger and its accompanying "Pancho" sauce. It's a keeper in more ways than one: With all that butter, cheese and mayo, you'll have to run a few extra miles on your treadmill to work this one off.

London Chophouse Roquefort Burger with Pancho Sauce

For the rest of our July recipe content please click on "In This Issue" links at the top upper right hand of this home page.

Find My Lost Recipe
 

Lost a favorite recipe? This is where you tell us which one so we can try to find it! What was the dish called? What was in it? Where'd you eat it? Who made it? Click the cupcake (below) to tell all and start the search:

Click cupcake (above) to start recipe-finder search!

Pie Revival

Lemon sponge, black-bottom, Montgomery, double-chocolate chess... Lost Recipes Found fans write us often in search of old-fashioned pie recipes. Two we've found this month? a buttery black-walnut rendition of pecan pie, and, a simple halved-peaches in cream custard pie. (Look under our State Fair favorites for one more: Jim Woodworth's Delicious Honey-Apple Pie. )

Vintage Summer Coolers

The chink-a-chink of ice in a glass of lemonade... fizz of cold soda poured over cool scoops of sherbet...slurp and drip of frozen-fruit pops enjoyed on the pool deck... Isn't that the sound of summer? Now that you're thirsty, here are two of our recent favorite summer-sweet quenchers.

State Fair Favorites

If you're interested in the best recipes American home-cooks can conjure, look no further than the food-competition tents at the nation's state fairs! We've been busy searching out blue-ribbon winning family heirloom recipes from all 50 states and will be showcasing them here year round. First up? A three-apple & honey pie from 82-year old Colorado State Fair blue-ribbon veteran Jim Woodworth, and, a simply perfect corn relish from Minnesota State Fair blue-ribbon queen, Barb Schaller. Also delicious? Orange/sugar-glazed tea cookies from 1961Tanana Valley State Fair Grand Champion Jo Ryman Scott, and, Oregon State Fair fixture Gerry Frank's favorite recipe from 50 years of judging the chocolate layer-cake competition.

Recipes Then & Now

To stay fresh, restaurants constantly update and upgrade the dishes they serve on their menus. But the old greats never truly go away. Hence our new feature: Restaurant Recipes Then and Now: We've asked long-standing restaurants to delve down into their recipe archives to resurrect classics from the past, which we'll feature here as the "Then" recipe, right next to the fresh/contemporary take on it, the "Now" recipe. We are pleased to feature Doris & Ed's of Highlands, N.J., as our first participant.

Better Left Lost

SPAMoni

Among the zaniest of State-Fair food contests, Hormel's SPAM cookery competitions appeal to punsters & blue-ribbon-wannabes alike. Spamoni—a porkified rendition of the much beloved pistachio/rum/cherry ice cream—has surfaced more than once. It didn't win in Minnesota in the mid-'70s, but actually took a third place ribbon at the Ohio State Fair in 2005. We agree with the Minnesota judges (sorry, Hormel) and have deemed this recipe “Better Left Lost.” But because I know you readers are curious, here's your chance to give it a try. Recipe courtesy of Hormel Foods.

SPAMoni Ice Cream

  • 1 qt. vanilla ice cream
  • 1 can SPAM, finely chopped
  • ½ lb pitted, dark, sweet cherries
  • 1 cup chopped pistachio nuts
  • 1 Tbsp rum flavoring

Soften ice cream just enough to be able to fold in the chopped SPAM, cherries, nuts and flavoring. Return ice cream to freezer until firm again. Serve in waffle cones or dishes.

Donate Your Old Cookbooks

Got old cookbooks too dilapidated to use? Don't dump them! Send them to us! They'll help in our efforts to search out old recipes readers have lost. editor@lostrecipesfound

Food Yarns

Podcasts of chefs and others with vintage recipe stories to share. Click links below.

Books to Buy
Jonathan's Bluegrass Table
Links You'll Like

These links will take you to sites with more vintage recipes, or, organizations working to save old recipes

Just Found!

Here are a few of our latest finds. Once we get them tested, we'll include the recipes in upcoming issues.

  • Prange's Sour Cream Muffins
  • Old-Fashioned Burnt Sugar Cake with Burnt Sugar Icing
  • Double-layer Chocolate Cheesecake
  • Blueberry Upside-Down Dake
  • The Brown Derby's Grapefruit Cake, LA
  • Chicken Hawaiian from Luau Restaurant, Miami Beach
  • Marshall Field's German Chocolate Cake with Coconut Pecan Frosting, Strawberry Muffins, Chilled Melon Soup and more
  • Don the Beachcomber's Pressed Duck
Still Looking

Wanna swap recipes? If you've got any of these, or have tips to help find them, let us know. Send your tips and recipes to editor@lostrecipesfound.com

  • House salad dressing from Double Dolphin restaurant (East Side, NYC, '70s)
  • Burney Bros. Orange Crunch Cake, Chicago
  • Stefanich's fried chicken, Joliet, restaurant closed 15 years ago
  • Lindyanne Cake from Southern IL
  • Recipes from closed St. Joseph's Health Resort, Wedron, IL
  • Alpine Bakery, Washington Hts., NY, (long-closed) muffins
  • Green Chile Mac from Senor Lucky's (gone), Santa Fe, NM
  • Weiboldts, or Tuzik Bakery's Tea Biscuits
  • Penne pasta with dried cherries figs, prosciutto, parmesan - sage cream sauce